The Divine Life

Why We Were Created
a blog by Eric Sammons
November 18, 2010

NY Times: The Pope is Darth Vader!

The NY Times recently ran another breathless article which pits the big, bad Catholic Church (a.k.a. The Evil Galactic Empire) against a group of plucky men and women (a.k.a. a small band of rebel freedom fighters) who just want to sit around and sing kumbaya in peace. I have to wonder: has the Times ever written an article about the Catholic Church that didn’t sound like the plot for Star Wars?

Here it is, with my comments in red:

Catholics in Belgium Start Parishes of Their Own

BUIZINGEN, Belgium — Willy Delsaert is a retired railroad employee with dyslexia who practiced intensively before facing the suburban Don Bosco Catholic parish to perform the Sunday Mass rituals he grew up with.

“Who takes this bread and eats,” he murmured, cracking a communion wafer with his wife at his side, “declares a desire for a new world.” [Well, so much for performing "the Sunday Mass ritual he grew up with" - this sounds like something you'd hear at a Unitarian service.]

With those words, Mr. Delsaert, 60, and his fellow parishioners are discreetly pioneering a grass-roots movement that defies centuries of Roman Catholic Church doctrine by worshiping and sharing communion without a priest. [I don't know how you can call them "pioneers" since Protestants have been doing this for centuries. Sounds more like they are late to the game to me.]

Don Bosco is one of about a dozen alternative Catholic churches [=non-Catholic churches] that have sprouted and grown in the last two years in Dutch-speaking regions of Belgium and the Netherlands. They are an uneasy reaction to a combination of forces: a shortage of priests, the closing of churches, dissatisfaction with Vatican appointments of conservative bishops and, most recently, dismay over cover-ups of sexual abuse by priests.

The churches are called ecclesias, the word derived from the Greek verb for “calling together.” [Rule #1 for dissenting Catholics: use NT Greek words to sound authentic.] Five were started last year in the Netherlands by Catholics who broke away from their existing parishes, and more are being planned, said Franck Ploum, who helped start an ecclesia in January in Breda, the Netherlands, and is organizing a network conference for the groups in the two countries.

At this sturdy brick church southwest of Brussels, men and women are trained as “conductors.” [At least they don't try to convince everyone that they are "priests".] They preside over Masses and the landmarks of life: weddings and baptisms, funerals and last rites. Church members took charge more than a year ago when their pastor retired without a successor. In Belgium, about two-thirds of clergymen are over 55, and one-third older then 65.

“We are resisting a little bit like Gandhi,” [a very little bit, I'd say] said Johan Veys, a married former priest who performs baptisms and recruits newcomers for other tasks at Don Bosco. “Our intention is not to criticize, but to live correctly. We press onward quietly without a lot of noise. [Considering the rapidly declining circulation of the NY Times, that might be true.] It’s important to have a community where people feel at home and can find peace and inspiration.”

Yet they appear to be on a collision course with the Vatican and the Catholic Church in Belgium. [Yes, I'm sure the big, bad Vatican will issue a fatwa and make sure these people are killed for their blasphemy...O wait a minute, Catholics don't do that...] The Belgian church has been staggering from a sexual abuse scandal with 475 victims, and the resignation of the bishop of Bruges, Roger Vangheluwe, who last April admitted to years of molesting a boy who turned out to be his nephew.

In the view of Rome [and Jesus and the apostles and the saints and the Fathers and 2,000 years of Catholic teaching], only ordained priests can celebrate Mass or preside over most sacraments like baptisms and marriage. “If there are persons or groups that do not observe these norms, the competent bishops — who know what really happens — have to see how to intervene and explain what is in order and out of order if someone belongs to the Catholic Church,” the Rev. Federico Lombardi, director of the Vatican press office, said. [with some measure of exasperation, I'm sure]

[Oh, I give up - this is like shooting fish in a barrel. If you want to read more of this inanity, click here - but don't say I didn't warn you.]

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!

The Church

  1. You’re correct. Like this is new. To bad the scribblers at the Times just can’t read a book, and none of this would be news, at least to them. People have been wandering away from the Church for 2000 years. All you can do is pray for them.

    Comment by William D. Zeranski — November 18, 2010 @ 9:34 am
  2. Sorry Willy, but there’s no way Don Bosco would have approved. I bet his incorrupt remains are spinning.

    Comment by Kathy — November 18, 2010 @ 10:51 am
  3. Kathy,

    You miss read my post. Of course, Don Bosco won’t have approved.

    Comment by William D. Zeranski — November 18, 2010 @ 11:04 am
  4. “I find your lack of faith disturbing”

    Comment by c matt — November 18, 2010 @ 11:08 am
  5. William – I didn’t mean you. I mean that silly guy in Belgium who thinks he is “saying Mass.” I’m sorry for the misunderstanding.

    Comment by Kathy — November 18, 2010 @ 12:32 pm
  6. I probably should finish reading the article before I post a comment, but I really couldn’t help but laughing at the second comment you made on the grassroots movement. I mean, on that note, Catholicism could never really embody a “true” grassroots movement. Anything less than a legitimate mass is like you said, Unitarian or any other form of Protestantism.
    As to the comment on resisting like Ghandi, I find that Rachel Donadio’s article ended on the scene of a “young girl watched the flame flicker in memory of the 475 Belgian victims of sexual abuse.” I think what Donadio was trying to attempt was make an analogy to Ghandi’s passivity. However, using hindsight we are able to see that his passive aggressive style, like the young girl’s in the article, still contradicts their opposition, in this case the Catholic Church.

    Comment by Jack V — November 18, 2010 @ 12:34 pm
  7. Great comments Eric! Maybe one day the NY Times will get the memo and write the story as it should be. Though they still might use the Star Wars template where The Catholic Church = the Rebel Alliance, (not the Empire).

    Comment by Frank Weathers — November 18, 2010 @ 1:12 pm
  8. “Do not be so proud of this [dissenting prayer group] you’ve constructed, the power of this [disobedience] is insignificant next to the power of the [Eucharist].”

    Sorry, I couldn’t resist.

    Comment by Moff Tarkin — November 18, 2010 @ 2:00 pm
  9. Actually it’s not true that only priests can preside over marriages and baptisms. In fact, it’s not true that you have to be ordained at all, not even as a deacon. It’s not even illicit if you did not seek permission to preside over these sacraments either. But it’s highly encouraged. Despite that any Catholic in full communion can baptize anyone non-Christian whose never been baptized, it is neither common and nor should it be. As to marriage, the priest doesn’t “marry” anyone. The two people engaged marry each other, the priest or deacon or whomever is presiding over the ceremony is merely authenticating that marriage as a witness, but again, the Sacrament is between the two people. If the NY Times or the idiots in the Netherlands knew any of this, it might throw a wrench in their big idea to try and be deliberately defiant. Alas, this articl only reveals their ignorance of Scripture and Tradition and the teaching of the Magisterium.

    Comment by Das Erlibnis — November 18, 2010 @ 2:36 pm
  10. I wonder just how “big” a story this really is..to people who
    do not depend upon the NYT as their news source. I would love to
    know the actual numbers of Catholics “going their own way” as
    compared to those who remain faithful to the Body of Christ. That would be interesting and informative…worthy of making the news. My quess?…these people represent a small fraction
    of the Catholic population of these two countries. The Netherlands has for decades been a “hotbed” for dissent even before the sex scandal broke Tried un-successfully to write their own Cathechism. All this dissent is as much due to Modernism as current issues.

    Comment by Shamrock — November 18, 2010 @ 6:05 pm
  11. I am so fed up with this. God should only have to deal with his holiness the Pope. No one else. That is why we have a Catholic Church.

    Can you imagine the noise of 6 billion people screaming in your ear at once? Sounds pleasent? It isn`t.

    Comment by GABRIEL — November 18, 2010 @ 10:42 pm
  12. So many good burns! A couple times, I almost wanted to say, “No he didn’t!” to myself. Anyway, lol’d quite a few times. Thank you, sir. And God forgive these schism-meisters.

    Comment by Jack — November 19, 2010 @ 1:09 pm
  13. There is an ‘Old Catholic Church’ in our city. My Lutheran friend friend said, “They are not Catholics – only using the name to legitimate their church. They answer to no one and still get the tax-free status from the government.” I wonder how many are mis-using the name ‘Catholic’ and getting away with it.

    Comment by Zenaida — November 19, 2010 @ 3:33 pm
  14. Excellent fisking, sir. I tip my hat—oh, wait, I don’t wear one … I salute—no, rats, no cover … ah, well, may the Farce be with you.

    @ Zenaida: Actually, quite a few parishes are grouped under the name “Ecumenical Catholic” … which, of course, means crypto-Protestant.

    Comment by Tony Layne — November 21, 2010 @ 12:22 am

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

kvindelige viagra